Eating Red Meat

For decades, scientific studies have shown that eating high amounts of red meat, such as beef, pork, chicken and pork chops, can cause heart disease without getting it. That’s why the American Heart Association encourages you to limit the amount of “red meat” you eat. She recommends a Mediterranean diet that allows little or no red meat, as well as a low-fat, high-protein diet. Sources: 8

And yet the choice of where to eat is reinforced by everything you believe about red meat, from the idea that it’s not that bad to the belief that it’s good for you. A new analysis was published in the Journal of the American Heart Association (also here and here), and it contradicts everything Sources: 5, 8

It is rich in minerals, proteins, vitamins and antioxidants, which are not readily absorbed by plant foods such as iron. Despite the positive effects of red meat, previous studies have reported that red meat consumption is associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease and mortality. As previously reported in observational studies, “consumption of processed red meat in the United States has been associated with an increased risk of heart disease, stroke, diabetes, cancer, heart failure, and death for all reasons. Sources: 5

This article examines what research says about the amount of red meat that may be healthy but does not address the health benefits of other types of meat such as poultry and fish. However, there is evidence that eating a lot of red meat can increase the risk of heart disease, stroke, diabetes, cancer, heart failure and death. Sources: 2

Eating red meat can increase your risk of heart disease and cancer, as well as heart failure and death. However, research has linked regular red meat consumption to a lower risk of diabetes, cardiovascular disease, stroke, cancer and other health problems. Sources: 2

To complicate matters, some studies suggest that the type of red meat a person eats makes the biggest difference. Some types of meat, such as beef, pork, lamb, chicken and pork ribs, may be healthier than other types. Sources: 2

This is because they are unprocessed, contain no excess salt, fat or preservatives and are high in protein and fiber. Sources: 2

The researchers involved generally support the idea that red meat is associated with a range of health problems, including obesity, diabetes, heart disease and cancer. The new work does not say that all processed meat, or even all meat in general, is healthy. There could be other causes for the apparent link, including a person’s different food choice and lifestyle, he said. Sources: 4

For years, there has been a consensus among nutritionists that reducing the amount of red meat you eat is good for your health. Research has shown that people who eat red and processed meat are more likely to suffer from obesity, diabetes, heart disease, cancer and other health problems. Defenders argue that dietary studies cannot be conclusive because of the difficulty of measuring the effects of a single foodSources: 4, 7

However, general scientific evidence suggests that one should either eat less red meat or avoid it altogether. But a new study suggests limiting red consumption – meat consumption may not make much difference. Red meat is high in fat, cholesterol, sodium and other harmful chemicals, as well as other nutrients. Sources: 3, 7

The saturated fat content in beef appears to be at least partially responsible for some of its adverse health effects, including heart disease and cancer. That’s according to a new report and study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) on the health consequences of eating beef. Sources: 3

The public is wondering what to make of the nutrition studies, and the recent publication of a new study by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) has added further excitement and confusion to the issue. Sources: 1, 3

The new study does not question the increased risk of cancer from eating meat, but it is too early to conclude that people do not need to reduce their consumption of red or processed meat. Study after study has shown that eating red and processed meat is bad for health, so the World Health Organisation has classified red meat as likely to be carcinogenic, as well as its effects on blood pressure, heart disease and cancer. Sources: 1

Experts have urged people to continue eating steaks, sausages and bacon as there is no evidence of a link between red and processed meat consumption and cancer risk. Sources: 6

In a controversial move, a team of researchers branded the evidence linking red meat to serious health problems as’ unconvincing ‘and said that on average people can continue to enjoy processed meat, but not all of it. The guidance goes against the recommendations of health organisations, including the World Cancer Research Fund, which advised people to avoid processed meat and eat very little of it, limiting red meat to around three portions a week. Harkin advised his patients to rarely eat red meat – at most once a month – and to avoid all processed foods such as bacon, sausages, steaks, sausages and bacon. Sources: 0, 6

Cited Sources